Tooth and Claw

by
Nigel McCrery

Pantheon Books, February 2010, 313 pp.
ISBN: 978-0-307-37702-9

Genre: Mystery

Subgenre: Detective / Serial Killer
Reviewed: 4/12/2010

Reviewed by: Conan Tigard

Book Cover

Excerpt

In the Mortuary Outside of Braintree

"I'm having some . . .  problems . . . that means I need somewhere quiet to work," Lapslie said. "This mortuary is one of the most peaceful places I've found. I'd like to use it as a refuge, if I may."

"Problems as in medical problems?"

He sighed. "It's called synaethesia--" he began.

"Ah, a rare case where cross-wiring in the brain means that inputs from one sense can trigger responses in another sense," Jane said, straightening up from the corpse.

Lapslie was taken aback. "You've heard of it?"

"It's a fascinating illustration of how the brain works," she replied. "I have read several articles in neurology magazines concerning the things synaethesia can teach us about the way we interpret the vast flood of data that enters the brain every moment. Tell me, Mark -- what form does your synaethesia take? The most common, I believe, is where sounds give rise to the sensation of colour, although one of the more interesting ones I have come across is the man who can actually feel tastes on his skin. Chicken, apparently, is spiky, while wine is spherical and cold."

"With me," he said, taking a deep breath, "things that I hear get translated into tastes in my mouth. It's not everything, but most things I come across in everyday life cause me to have a reaction of some kind. Lorries are flavoured like asparagus. A fountain or a shower taste of cauliflower."

"Both of them vegetables," Jane observed.

"Badly chosen examples. My mobile phone makes me taste coffee when it rings. And, before you ask, your voice tastes of brandy and soda."

"There are worse things," she said, smiling. "You must have been asked that question so many times before."

"I have, but don't let that stop you asking anything you want. I realise it's an interesting subject for anyone who doesn't suffer from it."

"What does your voice taste of?" she asked.

Lapslie found himself frowning. Nobody had ever asked him that before. In fact, he'd never even thought about it before. "I don't think it tastes of anything," he said slowly, savouring the words as they came out and finding them lacking any flavour.

"That's instructive. What about your parents."

"I don't remember. They died when I was quite young."

"Have you always been synaethetic?"

"No -- it seemed to develop when I was a teenage, in a mild form, and it suddenly deteriorated about seven years ago. It's been stable since then, but over the past few days it's suddenly got a lot worse, to the point where it's stopping me from carrying out my investigations properly." Now that he had started speaking, he couldn't seem to stop. The words came spilling out of him. "And I think I'm beginning to hallucinate. I keep hearing drums. Loud drums."

She frowned. "But this is happening in reverse, surely? You are hearing a noise which is not there, implying that it is being triggered by something else. Does that happen?"

"Occasionally," he admitted. "There are one or two tastes or smells that cause the synaethesia to go into reverse. Seafood that's going off makes me hear high-pitched violins, for some reason. And when I first entered this mortuary, a year or so ago, the smell of the bodies and the bleach made me hear church bells."

Jane nodded. "And is that what's happening now? You're smelling something, and it's causing you to hear the sound of drums?"

"It's possible, I suppose, but what is it?"

"You said you had heard the sound before. When was that?"

Lapslie considered for a moment. "The first time was in Catherine Charnaud's house in Chigwell; the second time was on a roof used by the bomber in Braintree."

"And the cases are not connected?"

"We have no evidence that they are."

"If you ask me," Jane said, "and you usually do, I would suggest that there is a connection between the murders. They each have a certain smell about them that only you can pick up, and I don't mean the smell of death. Somehow, I believe you are smelling the murderer."

 

Synopsis

Detective Chief Inspector Mark Lapslie, who works for the Essex Police,  is put in charge of a case where a TV newsreader, Catherine Charnaud, is found dead on her bed and all of the flesh and muscles have been stripped away on her left arm from her elbow to her wrist. This gruesome act occurred when she was still alive.

Lapslie lives out in the countryside near Saffron Walden to escape the sounds of . . . . well, just about everything. Lapslie suffers from disease called synaethesia, which turns sounds he hears into tastes in his mouth. Some are pleasant and some are so strong and nasty that they can cause him to lean over and lose his lunch.

With the aid of Detective Sergeant Emma Bradbury, they begin investigating the murder of the semi-famous newsreader. While standing the room where Charnaud dies, Lapslie is able to hear drums that no one else seems to notice. Deciding that they need a profiler for the case, Emma contacts Eleanor Whittley, who is happy to help.

After bombing at a Braintree railway station where one man, Alec Wildish, is killed, Lapslie and Emma head across the street to a shopping mall where they suppose that the killer might have been standing on the roof and watching the destruction of the bomb exploding. Again, Lapslie hears drums as he approaches the edge of the roof.

Meanwhile, twenty-five year old Carl Whittley lives at home with his invalid father. His job is to take care of his father, which he does when he is not out and about. Carl likes to sped time out in the salt marshes where he collects animals he kills. Carl is also suffering from an itchy rash the is on his hands and body, but hasn't yet seen a doctor about it. For years, Carl has been killing random strangers. He always makes sure that he kills people in different manners and that no two people fir the same profile. He fears that he is running out of different types of people to kill.

When Carl learns from his mother, Eleanor, that she has been brought in by the Essex Police to profile the killer of Catherine Charnaud, he is excited that she will finally be working one of his murders. His mother, who no longer lives with Carl and his father, and who treats him rather coldly, lets Carl drive her to the scene of the murder, but does not let him into the house. Carl is disappointed by this, as he wanted to relive the murder, and is forced to wait out in the car.

So far, over the years, Carl has killed ten people. He always varies the time between each kill. And because he kills in different manners, no two murders have ever been linked together. Plus, since he kills different type of people: some old, some young, males, females, gay, straight, blue eyes, brown eyes, green eyes, no one is even looking for a serial killer.

While talking with Jane Catherall, the mortician at the Braintree Mortuary, Lapslie is able to figure out the the drums he has been hearing my be linked with an odor left behind by the killer. He doesn't know that Carl is suffering from Porphyria, a rare disorder that is passed down through families, in which an important part of hemoglobin, called heme, are not made properly. Because of this disorder, Lapslie is able to detect Carl, so Carl finally decides that his next victim will have to be Detective Chief Inspector Mark Lapslie.

Tooth and Claw is a the second mystery book starring Detective Chief Inspector Mark Lapslie and is written by Nigel McCrery.

 

Review

One of my favorite television shows is Criminal Minds. The shows follows seven FBI agents who track down and capture, or sometime kill, serial killers. So, I consider myself somewhat familiar with these vicious kind of killers.

In the beginning of Tooth and Claw, I was a little disturbed by the first killing in the book by Carl Whittley. After all, he strapped a woman to her bed naked, and while she was awake, he sliced off all of the skin and muscle down to the bone on her left arm from her elbow to her wrist. That is pretty gross. I was worried that the whole book would be like this and am happy to report that it isn't.

DCI Mark Lapslie is an extremely interesting main character. His struggle with synaethesia, his family, and his job made him really fascinating to me. I had never heard of synaethesia and like most people, I'm sure, am glad that I do not have it. I certainly wouldn't want all sounds turned into tastes on my tongue. Lapslie is a strong character, though, and I quite enjoyed tagging along with him and DS Emma Bradbury as they worked on solving two high-profile cases.

As for the serial killer, Carl Whittley, he is a bit of a freak. He likes to take animals that he has killed out in the marsh, bring them back to his shed, and pose them in the same manner as his human victims. Sure, you have to feel sorry for him too. His father, Nathaniel, is incapacitated both physically and mentally, and at age 25, Carl is responsible to caring for him. His mother, Eleanor, has moved out of the house and doesn't seem to want anything to do with either her husband or her son. She is about as cold-hearted as a person can get.

I did not feel hampered by not having read the first Detective Chief Inspector Mark Lapslie mystery entitled Still Waters. I am sure that there were references in this book to the things that occurred in Still Waters, but I didn't seem to notice. I was able to easily follow this story without having read the first book.

The tension in the last 75 pages or so had me sitting on the edge of my seat while I tried to read as fast as I could. I was just so into the story. The writing style of Nigel McCrery is wonderful and I found myself to be quite engrossed in this fast-paced tale of murder most foul. The grittiness of the story made a cringe a little at the beginning, but I think that author intended his readers to react that way.

Overall, Tooth and Claw is an excellent mystery story with twists and turns that kept me reading late into the night. In fact, last night I wanted to keep reading so badly, I just couldn't keep my eyes open anymore, no matter how much I wanted to or how hard I tried. I sure hope that there is another Detective Chief Inspector Mark Lapslie mystery book in the future. If there is, I cannot wait to get my hands on it.

I rated this book an 9 out of 10.

This site was created and is maintained by Conan Tigard
2010