The Dark Horse

(A Walt Longmire Mystery)

by
Craig Johnson

Viking, May 2009, 318 pp.
ISBN: 978-0-670-02087-4

Genre: Mystery

Subgenre: Sherriff / Western
Reviewed: 10/29/2009

Reviewed by: Conan & Nikki Tigard

Book Cover

Excerpt

The Cheyenne Nation

I left Dog in the truck so he wouldn't greet the Cheyenne Nation with too much enthusiasm and noticed that Bill didn't offer me the rifle or accompany me as I walked the ten yards back in the shale dust; the red road stretched to the blue horizon. I stopped about six feet away, as if I didn't know the Bear. His head stayed back, and his eyes remained closed as he spoke softly. "What seems to be the problem, Officer?"

"Careful, you'll blow my cover." I glanced back, but Bill hadn't moved and continued to occupy the passenger seat. I turned around. "You broke down?"

He still remained motionless. "We are resting."

I noticed the rolled-up sleeves and the grease and dirt on his folded arms. "So, you're broken down."

"Resting."

I nodded and approached a little closer, leaning against the wavering flanks of Rezdawg, the green and white paint looking as though it had been applied with a spatula. "What are you doing out here?"

"It is the Rez. I live here."

"Here. Specifically."

One eye opened slightly to regard me. "Waiting for you."

"Uh-huh, and how did you know I'd be out here?"

He looked irritated that I ruined his sunbath and finally opened both eyes and swiveled his neck to look at me. "I did not." He flicked her eyes at the truck. "She did."

"I see."

"Where are you going?"

I glanced north, where the country got wilder and the breaks of the river more jagged, then at Bill, who had turned with the rifle now up and on the seat. "I think I'm being driven out into the country to be executed."

Henry nodded, and the eyes closed again. "Nice day for it."

"Yep."

 

Synopsis

In Absalom, Wyoming, Mary Barsad was arrested for shooting her husband, Wade, in the head six times while he slept after he had burned down their barn that contained Mary's eight horses. When Mary arrives in Sherriff Walt Longmire's jail cell, Walt finds a woman that will barely talk and is not interested in eating.

Over the next few days, with as little talking as she does, Walt becomes convinces that Mary is innocent. Mary believes that her favorite horse, Black Diamond Wahoo Sue, a champion cutting horse, was killed in the fire. When tries to commit suicide, Walt realizes that he must do something to help her. He drives over to Absolom and pretends to be Eric Boss of Boss Insurance. There, he meets Juana, who works at the hotel Walt is staying at, and her pre-teen son, Benjamin. 

While investing the burned down house and barn, he runs across an old cowpoke named Hershel Vanskike. Hershel had worked for Mary and was the first to find her crumpled on the ground outside of her house after the killing and still holding a gun. Walt quickly realizes that Hershel is a man that he can trust. In the local bar, which is missing the "b" on the sign, so Walt calls it the AR, he runs across a foul character named Cliff Cly. Cliff is drunk and wants to fight Walt, but Walt avoids him and Cliff challenges him to sign up for the Powder-River-Pound-Down-Tough-Man Contest the next night.

That night, Walt hears two men talking in the AR and sneaks in through the mudroom. When he steps on a squeaky board, the lights suddenly go out and the bartender soon enters the mudroom with a shotgun. Walt is able to disarm the man and knock him out, but the other man shoots a few rounds in his direction as escapes out the front.

Realizing that there is much more going on in this small town than meets the eye, Walt knows that he must be very careful in his undercover investigation or he may end up dead like Wade.

The Dark Horse is a the fifth mystery book starring Sherriff Walt Longmire and is written by Craig Johnson.

 

Review

I do love a good mystery . . . and The Dark Horse is just that. I also enjoy a good ol' fashioned western. And while this is a not a western in the traditional sense, the story does take place in a small, modern-day town in Wyoming. Sherriff Walt Longmire is a highly likable main character that I instantly bonded with. I believe in his sense of righteousness and to his belief that the truth must be revealed, no matter the cost. After all, the law is the law.

It was nice to be shocked and surprised, and The Dark Horse does this a few times. The plot of the story is a good one and the writing is excellent. What I liked best about this hard-boiled sheriff is that he doesn't use a lot of cuss words, although his second in command, Vic, sure does. I also loved the fact that Walt found the perfect name for his dog . . . Dog.

Craig Johnson does a fantastic job with his storytelling and has created a wonderful character in Walt Longmire. The pace of the story is quick and I found that I didn't ever want to stop reading. I just had to find out if Mary was guilty of killing her husband, or if someone else did it. If if it wasn't her, who was it? This is the perfect book to be reading while sitting in front of a fire, wrapped in a blanket as the snow falls outside the window.

Overall. The Dark Horse is an excellent western mystery involving a sheriff that I would love to have working on my case if I were ever wrongfully accused.

I rated this book a 9 out of 10.

The woman’s point of view:

So, I didn’t love this book nearly as much as my husband did.  Maybe it’s a “guys” novel.  However, I did enjoy it and feel like it was well written.  I enjoyed the quirkiness and understated humor – especially in the naming of people and things, i.e. Dog, The Cheyenne Nation, etc.  I liked the author’s turn of phrase and way of representing the oddball people of this small western town.  I know this author has several books in this series that happen before this one takes place – and I think that maybe I would have enjoyed this one much more if I had read the others first.  I felt like there was a lot of history with the Sheriff, Dog, and the people in the Sheriff’s life, and had I had that background, it might have enhanced this story.  I did think that there was a little too much description of scenery, but that’s just my bias.  I tend to like the relational aspects of fiction more than the descriptions.

Overall, I enjoyed The Dark Horse and felt like it was an entertaining read.

I rated this book a 7 out of 10.

This site was created and is maintained by Conan Tigard
2009