Hell Girl

(Volume 1)

by
Miyuki Eto

original story by
The Jigoku Shouji Project

Del Rey, January 2008, 202 pp.
ISBN: 978-0-345-49747-5

Genre: Comics
Subgenre: Manga
Reviewed: 1/27/2008

Reviewed by: Conan Tigard

Book Cover

Manga Page

 

Review

Ai Enma has a job. Even though she is a third year student in middle school, when someone logs onto her website, Hell Correspondence, at midnight and types in the name of a person that they hate, then she, Hell Girl, will come and help them. But it is a double-edged sword. Not only will she take the person that is hated to Hell, but when the person who contacted her dies, their soul will go to Hell and live in eternal damnation.

In the first story, Mari Shimizu is caught shoplifting. She is saved by fellow student Satsuki Hayase. For saving her, Satsuki begins by asking small favors which soon leads to big favors. It all becomes to much for Mari who writes to Hell Girl and Satsuki is soon dead and living in Hell. In the second story, Hiromi Kasuga is an honored culinary arts student. She is opening a small pastry shop and her old boss, Morisaki, who owns another pastry shop, shows up to check it out. He tells her that a reporter wants to do a story on her and would like some of her recipes. Hiromi hands them over and Morisaki claims them as his own in the story, which turns out to be about him. He then goes on to spread nasty rumors about Hiromi and her new shop. After Hiromi ends up in the hospital for stress -related problems, her best friend Yuki writes to Hell Girl and Morisaki soon disappears. In the third story, Sakura lands the roll of a lifetime. She will be playing Hell Girl in a new drama. Her best friend, Kaoru, is happy for her friend's good fortune. But when rumors are spread that the make-up artist is a stalker, he gets fired. Soon after, some lighting falls onto Sakura and paralyzes her so that she will never walk again. Kaoru shows up in Sakura's hospital room looking like Sakura and informs her that she now has the part of Hell Girl. Sakura figures out that it was Kaoru who did all these things to her and asks the real Hell Girl to help her out. Very soon, Kaoru is living in her own personal Hell. As for the fourth and fifths stories, one is about a veterinarian who kills the animals that are brought in rather than save them and the other is about a teacher who tries to molest one of his middle school students.

Hell Girl - Volume 1 is a manga book written and drawn by Miyuki Eto and was originally created by The Jigoku Shoujo Project. This collection was Translated and Adapted by Gemma Collinge and Lettered by North Market Street Graphics. This book contains the following periods:

Chapter One: From Within the Darkness

Chapter Two: Sweet Trap

Chapter Three: Fallen Angel

Chapter Four: The inaudible Scream

Chapter Five: Dangerous Extracurricular Activities

There are also some special extras in the following sections: 1) Honorifics Explained, 2) About the Creator, 3) Translation Notes, and a Preview of Volume 2, although the preview is in Japanese. The book reads from right to left and back to front, just like a book from Japan. This manga book is intended for readers ages 16 and up.

I was very excited when I saw the cover of Hell Girl - Volume 1 and read the back of the book to see what it was about. After all, the cover is pretty cool-looking. But when I started reading, the first story was jumbled and confusing. Maybe the translation and adaptation wasn't very good, or it was poorly written. I'm not really sure where the problem was. I really enjoyed the character Ai Enma and think that she is totally awesome. But we really don't get to know her at all. How did she get these powers? Is she a demon spawn? Does she work for the devil? Is she from Hell itself? None of these questions were answered in this book. The other problem I had with this collection of stories is that all five stories are stand-alone tales. There really do seem to be a lot of angry third year middle school students at that one school. It is basically the same story told five different times with different characters. I always knew what was going to happen, so it became kind of tedious. On the other hand, the artwork is great and the stories are interesting, but repetitious. I find it hard to believe that just because some bad person is picking on some of these characters that they are willing to have this person killed and then when they die, they will live in eternal damnation for the rest of time. Wouldn't they just confront the nasty person and get them out of their lives rather than having an eternity of torture thrust upon them? That certainly isn't a choice I would make, nor would most people, I believe. Overall, Hell Girl - Volume 1 is readable, but the concept is flawed and the book wasn't very well executed. There are too many questions that were not answered and the reader is left confused and bewildered. Maybe things will be better in Hell Girl - Volume 2. I can only hope so.

I rated this book a 5 out of 10.

This site was created and is maintained by Conan Tigard
2008